Does Writing Down Goals Help? The Harvard Study Myth
You have probably heard that 3% of a Harvard or Yale class wrote down their goals and later out-earned everyone else. Librarians at both universities looked for that study and never found it. Here is what the research does show.
The famous Harvard or Yale written-goals study is an urban legend: librarians at both universities say they have never found it. Writing down goals still has some support, though. The stronger evidence is for what you do after writing: tracking progress, recording it and sharing it, plus a clear plan for when and where you will act.

Few productivity claims travel as far as this one. A class of graduates is asked whether they have written down their goals. Only 3% have. Decades later, that 3% is said to earn far more than everyone else.
It is a great story, and it gets used to sell planners, courses and coaching. But is writing down goals worth it if the study behind the story never happened?
The short version: the study is a myth, the habit is not useless, and the parts that help most are the ones the legend leaves out. If you keep goals in a goal tracker or a notebook, this is what the evidence says about using it well.
- No one has found the Harvard or Yale written-goals study. Librarians at both universities call it an urban legend.
- A small study at Dominican University of California found that people who wrote their goals down rated their progress higher than people who did not.
- The biggest gains in that study came from sending a friend weekly progress reports, not from writing alone.
- A review of 138 experiments found that monitoring progress helps people reach goals, more so when progress is written down or shared.
- Plans that say when, where and how you will act had a medium-to-large effect across 94 tests.
The Harvard/Yale goals study: what the legend claims
The story comes in two main versions. In one, it is a Yale graduating class. In the other, it is a Harvard class. The details shift, but the shape stays the same:
- Graduates are asked if they have clear, written goals
- About 3% say yes
- Years later, that 3% is said to earn about ten times as much as the rest combined
The numbers are neat, which is part of why they spread. They also make writing goals sound like a magic act: one evening with a pen, and a lifetime of higher income follows.
What Harvard and Yale librarians found: no such study
Harvard Library answers this question on its public help pages, because people ask it so often. In its answer about the "Harvard Goals Study", the librarians say they have never been able to find such a study. They add that Yale librarians could not find the Yale version either.
The library also checks the most common source given for the claim, Mark McCormack's book What They Don't Teach You at Harvard Business School. It says the book does not reference any such study.
The verdict from the two universities themselves: it is an urban legend. Nobody has produced the survey, the data or the follow-up that the story describes.
Librarians at both universities have looked and found no such study.
With no study, there is no data behind this number.
The research below points to tracking, sharing and planning as the parts that do most of the work.
Also not what the evidence says. A myth being false does not make the habit useless.
The Dominican University study: writing helped, reporting helped more
Psychology professor Gail Matthews at Dominican University of California ran her own study of the idea. Her research summary describes it like this:
- Who: 267 people recruited from businesses, organisations and networking groups; 149 completed it
- Where: the United States, Belgium, England, India, Australia and Japan
- How long: goals for a four-week period
- Measure: at the end, people rated their own progress
People were randomly placed in five groups. Each group did a little more than the one before:
- Thought about their goals but did not write them down
- Wrote their goals down
- Wrote goals and action commitments
- Also sent those commitments to a supportive friend
- Also sent the friend a weekly progress report
What she found
Average goal achievement rose with each step, from 4.28 for the group that did not write anything to 7.6 for the group that sent weekly progress reports. Writing goals down beat not writing them. But the weekly progress report to a friend gave the highest score of all, higher than every other group.
A Dominican University news item put it in percentages: more than 70% of those who sent weekly updates said they had fully reached their goal or were more than halfway there, compared with 35% of those who kept their goals to themselves without writing them down.
- It was small: 149 people finished.
- Progress was self-rated, not measured.
- It ran for four weeks.
- It was presented at a conference of the Athens Institute for Education and Research; Harvard Library notes that, as far as it knows, the results have not been published.
Does writing down goals help? Stronger research says tracking matters most
For firmer ground, it helps to look at reviews that pool many experiments. In 2016, researchers at the universities of Sheffield and Leeds and the University of North Carolina reviewed 138 studies with 19,951 people. They asked a simple question: does getting people to monitor their progress help them reach their goals?
Most of the goals were about health, such as eating better, losing weight or quitting smoking. The findings:
- Prompting people to monitor their progress improved goal attainment
- The more often people checked their progress, the more it helped
- The effect was larger when progress was physically recorded, such as written in a log
- It was also larger when progress was reported to others or made public
That matches the Dominican result. Writing a goal once is a start. Writing down how it is going, again and again, is where the measurable gains showed up.
If-then plans: why the "when and where" matters
A second line of research looks at how a goal is written. Psychologists Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "implementation intentions": plans that say in advance when, where and how you will act.
They found a medium-to-large effect on reaching goals. These plans helped people get started, stay on track when distracted and let go of approaches that were not working.
- Goal: I want to read more.
- If-then plan: When I get into bed, I will read ten pages before I pick up my phone.
- Goal: Save money this year.
- If-then plan: On payday, I will move a set amount to savings before I pay anything else.
So the pen does matter, but for a different reason than the legend suggests. It works best when it turns a wish into a specific next action.
How to write down goals so it actually helps: five steps
These steps use what the studies above found. None of them needs more than a few minutes.
Write the goal in one specific line
"Get fit" is hard to check. "Run 5 km without stopping by 31 March" tells you when you are done. Keep the list short, the way Franklin kept his virtues to one-line rules.
Add an if-then plan
Under each goal, write one line that starts with "When" or "If" and names a time, place or cue. Then put the first action on a short, specific to-do list for this week.
Record your progress often
This is the step with the best evidence. Note each run, each page read, each amount saved. A tick in a notebook counts; the point is that it is written, not just remembered.
Expect it to take a while before the routine feels easy. Our look at how long it takes to form a habit found that times varied widely from person to person.
Tell one person and report back
In the Dominican study, a short weekly update to a friend gave the biggest boost. Pick someone supportive and send two lines each Friday: what you did, and what is next.
Review it every week
Once a week, read the goal, look at your log and adjust the plan. Change the "when" if it keeps failing. Drop a goal that no longer matters; that is also progress. At the end of the year, our end-of-year reflection questions help you look back before you choose new goals.
Doing this in RytePad
Paper works well for every step above. If you would rather keep goals and progress on your phone and computer, here is one way to set it up in RytePad:
- Goals for the one-line goal. Write each goal in Goals and tick it off when you reach it. The free plan holds 40 long-term goals. Pro ($14.97 a year) adds monthly goals, on their own tab. Your Stats shows how many long-term goals you have achieved.
- Daily Tasks for the if-then plan. Add the next action to the day it is due and give it a reminder at the time you want; the morning summary lists it that day too. A weekly check-in can repeat every week on the day you pick. The free plan allows 25 tasks a day.
- Diary for the progress log. A short entry each evening records what you did. The private diary is encrypted with AES-256, like everything else you write in the app.
- Checklists for repeated steps. If a goal breaks into steps, a checklist keeps them in one place. The free plan has 10 checklists of 25 items.

RytePad will not send progress reports to a friend for you, and it has no templates or shared workspaces. It keeps the goal, the plan and the record in one private place; the weekly check-in is still yours.
Write it down, then track it
Goals, daily tasks and a private diary for your progress log. Free, encrypted and on any device.
Writing down goals: your questions answered
Is the Harvard written goals study real?
No one has found it. Harvard Library says its librarians have never been able to find such a study, that Yale librarians could not find the Yale version either, and that it appears to be an urban legend.
Are you 42% more likely to reach goals if you write them down?
That figure is widely repeated, but we could not find it in the Dominican University research summary we checked. The summary reports average progress ratings: writing goals down scored higher than not writing them, and weekly progress reports to a friend scored highest.
Does writing down goals actually help?
There is some evidence that it does, mostly from one small, unpublished study. The stronger evidence is for monitoring progress, especially when it is written down or shared, and for if-then plans that say when, where and how you will act.
Is it better to write goals by hand or type them?
The studies here did not compare the two. In the Dominican study, participants typed their goals into a survey. What mattered more was recording progress often and reporting it to someone.
How often should I review written goals?
The review of 138 studies found that more frequent monitoring helped more. A short weekly review, plus a quick note whenever you make progress, is a practical rhythm for most people.
The bottom line
The Harvard and Yale goals study does not exist, so the famous 3% and the tenfold income are not evidence of anything. Writing down goals is still a sensible start. The research that holds up points past the first page: write a specific next step, record your progress often and tell someone how it is going.
Write your goal down tonight, then log the first step.
Keep goals, daily tasks and a private progress diary in one place with RytePad. Free, private and on any device.
Try RytePad free →Free plan with no time limit · No card · Works in any browserSources
- Harvard Library. Ask a Librarian FAQ on the "Harvard Goals Study". ask.library.harvard.edu/faq/82314
- Matthews, G. Research summary on goal setting (written goals, commitment and accountability). Dominican University of California. dominican.edu (PDF)
- Dominican University of California. News item on Gail Matthews's goal-setting research, 2016. media.dominican.edu (PDF)
- Harkin, B., Webb, T. L., Chang, B. P. I., Prestwich, A., Conner, M., Kellar, I., Benn, Y., & Sheeran, P. (2016). Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 142(2), 198–229. doi.org/10.1037/bul0000025
- Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69–119. doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(06)38002-1
Related reading
- How long does it take to form a habit?What four studies found, and a ten-week plan
- Benjamin Franklin's daily routineHow he tracked 13 virtues in a little book
- How to write a to-do list you will finishSeven steps built on the research
- Best goal tracking appsCompared and ranked
- Use RytePad as a goal trackerLong-term and monthly goals in one place
